
Do you remember when being a know-it-all was a criticism? Most of us are willing to accept we know a lot about a little, and very little about a lot. Yet leaders are expected to have all the answers.
A challenging climate demands strong leadership, the ability to make decisions, even when the way ahead isn’t clear. As a modern CEO, you’re expected to have the inside track on everything from supply chain to agentic AI, brand management to sustainability, capital markets to geopolitics.
To be unsure and to ask questions can imply weakness. Yet there is real strength in numbers when organisations move away from a culture of control towards one that empowers people to question, learn, listen and adapt.
Today’s leader is painfully aware that these systems are lacking. Manifesto Growth Architects’ Truth of Modern Leadership research reveals that four in five leaders have avoided asking a question because they felt they should already know the answer, 74% have felt out of their depth with technology central to their strategy, and more than half have told their board what it wanted to hear rather than what they really believed.
To succeed as a leader when organisations demand so much specialist knowledge across so many different disciplines you need access to the right expertise. It means having a system around you as CEO that provides the people and intelligence that empower you to make the informed strategic decisions you were hired for. For this to happen, we first need to dismantle some firmly entrenched prejudices.
Slaughter the unicorn
For one, today’s CEO no longer operates as the tightly-defined strategic leader they should be. The job description has become some amorphous, head-of-every-department role. One that has become wider than any one individual can master. It’s seemingly an all-seeing, all-knowing unicorn.
Yet leaders’ core competency hasn’t changed. Our research found that leaders are most confident managing their organisation’s culture (95%) and reputation (90%) and least confident in fast-moving technical areas. Yes, given the non-stop coverage of AI, they wish they’d developed an understanding of AI (31%) and cyber resilience (21%) faster, but given the rate these areas expand, is deep expertise really feasible? Or even desired at this level?
Feasible or otherwise, leaders feel that to appear worthy they must somehow ‘fake it ‘til they make it’. And without a realistic way of becoming an expert in everything, our research discovered they simply ‘perform’ it. “It’s all about the art of appearing indestructible,” one CEO told us, “even if it’s a mask.”
That mask is slipping. Faking confidence may deal with a tricky conversation in the moment, but CEOs acknowledge that lacking security in their understanding of an issue hampers confidence to make decisions and that has significant, real-world impacts on business performance.
According to McKinsey, only 20% of senior executives believe they excel at decision-making and 61% say whatever decision-making time they have is being used ‘ineffectively’. “A whole organisation can go into paralysis if you take too long to make a decision,” says Karen Blackett, CBE, underlining the risk.
Ironically, acknowledging you know less can help move that decision-making forward. Back in the early 2000s, during the Iraq War, then Secretary of State Donald Rumsfeld was roundly mocked for admitting that what the US really needed to know was the ‘unknown unknowns’. For a bullish first-world nation with the world’s intelligence network at its fingertips, the idea that there even were ‘unknown unknowns’ was unconscionable.
Scoffing commentators may not have realised it at the time, but the most important questions any leader can ask are, “What is it that I don’t know yet?” and “What am I missing?” As the new world changes, capabilities shift, new skills emerge — ones that haven’t even been considered yet. Leaders are responsible for recognising the shift, bringing in new skills and helping people evolve. Asking the unasked questions is often where great leaders excel.
Build leadership belief from the ground up
But to excel, the burden must be shared. More than half (52%) of leaders already feel there is no-one with whom they can think completely openly. More than a fifth (22%) have made a decision of significant consequence without at least one person to talk it through with first.
The pace of change isn’t going to slow, demands aren’t going to get any less insistent but with that understanding comes opportunity. We have an opportunity to redesign the structures, expectations and support around leadership. Set long-term ambitions, but check in on progress and change course where needed. Hand the authority to make decisions to those who are best equipped to wield it, rather than the person at the top of the tree simply because there’s no further for the buck to go.
Leaders aren’t in the business of removing uncertainty and they shouldn’t have their fingers in every pie. Their role is to create clarity, confidence and the conditions for the organisation to move forward. To set direction, develop capabilities and create accountability that helps a wider network of people act, adapt and deliver together. To do this, their organisations need move from systems based around control, to a growth architecture, support structures built around learning, listening and adapting to change rather than simply cataloguing it.
Nick is a founding partner of Manifesto, bringing 30 years’ experience in customer-led growth and commercial transformation. Previously a Managing Director at Accenture, he held senior marketing roles at British Gas and Alliance & Leicester (now Santander). He is Chair of The Marketing Group of Great Britain and an Honorary Fellow of The Marketing Society.
Do you remember when being a know-it-all was a criticism? Most of us are willing to accept we know a lot about a little, and very little about a lot. Yet leaders are expected to have all the answers.
A challenging climate demands strong leadership, the ability to make decisions, even when the way ahead isn’t clear. As a modern CEO, you’re expected to have the inside track on everything from supply chain to agentic AI, brand management to sustainability, capital markets to geopolitics.
To be unsure and to ask questions can imply weakness. Yet there is real strength in numbers when organisations move away from a culture of control towards one that empowers people to question, learn, listen and adapt.