
AI has been described as the great leveller of our time. Yet new research from PA Consulting suggests that organisations cannot assume those benefits will emerge automatically.
With the average worker using AI four times a day, providing access to the technology is proving much easier than ensuring that value is realised consistently across an organisation.
PA’s study of 2,000 private and public sector workers across multiple industries reveals a critical challenge: many organisations are introducing AI without fully redesigning how employees use it, how work is assessed or where decisions sit. Often, employees are left to determine these outcomes themselves.
Too often, AI is deployed without a clear strategy for what it is intended to achieve or how it should improve work. This lack of direction can lead to uneven benefit distribution and increase the risk of over-reliance on the technology.
To realise value consistently across the workforce, leaders need to set clear outcomes for AI and rethink how expertise is developed, how judgement is exercised and how responsibility is assigned.
Leaders must set the direction and remove the obstacles
PA’s research reveals a clear difference between the AI experiences of those in entry-level, junior, and non-managerial roles (individual contributors) with those in senior leadership roles.
Even allowing for the fact that senior leaders report higher usage, they report substantially greater gains in productivity, capability and quality than individual contributors: 70% of senior leaders say AI enables them to do things they previously could not, compared with 38% of individual contributors. Similarly, 72% of senior leaders report quality improvements from AI, compared with 43% of individual contributors.
Rather than acting as an equalising force, AI appears to benefit employees who already have the experience, confidence and professional judgement to recognise what a good output looks like and challenge it when necessary.
Part of the reason for this may be that AI is changing the very activities through which expertise is traditionally acquired. Dean Collins, people and technology adoption expert at PA, notes that early in many careers, people learn by being close to work that AI threatens to replace. He says: “Junior employees are missing out on opportunities to build expertise, judgement and confidence through observation, trial, feedback and repetition.
“With AI doing more of the heavy lifting, traditional on-the-job learning is compressed, if not entirely bypassed,” he continues. “As a result, this cohort of workers may see slower skill growth and reduced long-term adaptability. Organisations need to think carefully about the learning opportunities they will provide in their place.”
For example, if AI removes apprenticeship tasks, organisations must deliberately design new ways for employees to develop expertise through mentoring, structured observation, challenge and practice. Otherwise, short-term efficiency may come at the expense of long-term capability.
Capability or dependence?
As AI usage increases, so does trust in it. PA’s research found a net trust of 92% among people who have used AI for four years or more, compared with 24% among newer users.
Yet the data also casts a shadow. One-fifth of employees feel overly dependent on AI, rising to 28% among frequent AI users. Heavy users are also more than 2.5 times as likely as light users to favour an AI answer over their own judgement, even when the two disagree.
Employees need to understand where AI systems can fall short and how to distinguish an adequate output from an excellent one. As AI handles more routine work, leaders must make their own judgement more visible.
“The best leaders make time to explain the difference between okay, good and brilliant,” says Collins. “If people have fewer opportunities to build judgement by doing the work themselves, you have to create other opportunities for them to develop it.”
One way to drive change, Collins adds, is to “set AI to be less flattering and more challenging. Leaders in particular should be doing that for their systems, because they are already the least likely to be challenged.”
While it’s widely accepted that AI systems require a human-in-the-loop, Collins proposes a practical method for defining the extent. He suggests two criteria: value and risk. Low-value, low-risk work may be more fully automated. Human involvement should increase with the consequences of a decision.
Building on this, Warwick Goodall, global roads and mobility lead at PA, recommends mapping role-specific workflows, identifying important decisions and defining how people and AI should work together. He adds: “The risk of dependency means that human expertise always remains essential – either in the workflow mapping, or in the live review cycle.”
Redesigning responsibility
As systems become more autonomous, AI also complicates accountability. PA’s survey found that two-thirds of workers believe accountability remains with the output owner whatever AI’s involvement. But 34% said they feel less responsible for quality when AI is involved.
This fog of responsibility has consequences: just over a quarter of workers (26%) feel uncomfortable signing off work that has been shaped by AI.
For Collins, leaders need to look for signs of interrogation and explanation, not just increased outputs. Employees should be able to explain AI-assisted decisions.
He adds: “A team using AI selectively but making higher-quality decisions may outperform one with heavier usage and weaker judgement. The goal isn’t ubiquitous use. It’s capable and accountable use.”
As organisations embed AI more deeply into critical processes, accountability increasingly extends beyond individual outputs to questions of governance, oversight and operational management. Leaders need clarity not only on who owns decisions, but also on the level of dependence placed on external AI systems and providers.
Ensuring that work works
The organisations that realise the greatest value from AI will be those that treat it as workforce transformation, not simply technology deployment. They’ll be clear about the outcome they want AI to achieve and create the conditions for success through leadership, learning, capability, accountability and trust.
The firms that get it right may not have the most AI users. But they will have those who have learned to work differently and better.
For more information please visit paconsulting.com.
AI has been described as the great leveller of our time. Yet new research from PA Consulting suggests that organisations cannot assume those benefits will emerge automatically.
With the average worker using AI four times a day, providing access to the technology is proving much easier than ensuring that value is realised consistently across an organisation.
PA’s study of 2,000 private and public sector workers across multiple industries reveals a critical challenge: many organisations are introducing AI without fully redesigning how employees use it, how work is assessed or where decisions sit. Often, employees are left to determine these outcomes themselves.